Our ice cream is handmade from scratch in small batches daily! We are always creating new flavors so check back often to see what’s new! Flavors are subject to change.
The Classic Flavors
These classic ice cream flavors are always available for scoops and pints at all three of our ice cream shops
Bananas Foster
Roasted banana ice cream, caramel rum sauce, banana pieces GF
Breakfast Milk-a-licious
Fruity Pebble ice cream, Fruit Loops & Cap’n Crunch Berries pieces
Carmelita Crumble
Salted Caramel ice cream, oat cookie streusel, Sam Old Moses bourbon caramel swirl
Cherry Goat
Goat cheese ice cream, Roasted cherries & salted fudge swirl
GF
Chocolate
The best milk chocolate ice cream GF
Chocolate Tornado
Dark chocolate ice cream, soft baked brownie chunks, salted fudge swirl
Cookie Butter
Speculoos cookie butter ice cream with Biscoff cookie chunks
Cookies & Cream
Oreo ice cream & Oreo pieces
Elemental Espresso Crunch
Elemental coffee ice cream, hazelnuts & salted fudge swirl GF
Hazelnut Fudge
Nutella ice cream & fudge swirl GF
Madagascar Vanilla
Award winning vanilla bean ice cream GF
Mediterranean Strawberry
Fresh strawberry ice cream with a hint of balsamic vinegar & strawberry jam swirl GF
Peanut Butter Cookie
Peanut butter ice cream & chunks of soft peanut butter cookies
Salted Cowboy Cookie
Salted vanilla ice cream, chunks of oatmeal chocolate chip cookies
Turtley Rad
Malted vanilla ice cream, pecans, caramel & fudge swirl.
Seasonal Flavors
Flavors that are here for the season, typically several months
Key Lime Pie
Key Lime ice cream, key lime curd swirl, pieces of graham cracker crust
Limited Release
A single batch new ice cream flavor, when it’s gone it’s gone! Typically in the case for a week or two but can sell out sooner!
Peanut Butter Cup
Chocolate ice cream, peanut butter swirl GF
Gusto’s Cacio E Pepe
Pecorino Romano ice cream, cracked black pepper GF
Okie Cornbread
Sweet cornbread ice cream, molasses, cornbread chunks
Vegan
These ice cream flavors are dairy-free and vegan! Some are classic, some are seasonal and some are limited release.
Fluffernutter
Peanut butter oat milk ice cream, made from scratch marshmallow fluff
Limited V, DF, GF
Apple Cider
pumpkin spiced apple sorbet
Limited V, DF, GF
State Fair Strawberry Lemonade
strawberry and lemon sorbet
Limited V, DF, GF
GF= Gluten Friendly
DF= Dairy Free
V= Vegan
TO VIEW A LIST OF INGREDIENTS FOR EACH FLAVOR PLEASE CLICK HERE.